Books and Bagels Book Discussion on The Sisters Brothers by Patrick deWitt
Rating: The Sisters Brothers received ratings between 1.0 and 5.0 with an average rating of 3.58.
Review: The reviews were mixed; members either really enjoyed the novel or really detested the novel.
- Many members found the novel highly entertaining. Members found the novel a unique, clever episodic Western.
- Members discussed whether or not the story was successful as a loosely based picaresque novel.
- Members appreciated deWitt’s dark humor and members were mystified by how they found themselves laughing at very grisly elements. There was much discussion about the techniques used by deWitt to pull off this feat. It shows his true talent as an author and members agreed that the novel was worthy of The Man Booker Prize.
- Members adored the witty banter between the two brothers and the well-developed brother relationship.
- Members liked watching Eli, the younger brother, develop as an independent person over the course of the novel.
- Members found the use of first person to be refreshing and felt the structure utilized served the novel well.
- Members enjoyed the inconspicuous social commentary exhibited throughout the book.
- Several members appreciated the bare-bones acknowledgements at the end of the book and they wish more authors would employ this technique.
- Members really appreciated the facilitator presentation about the author and felt they better understood Patrick deWitt and his style.
- Members learned that Patrick deWitt is a huge fan of Roald Dahl. One member enjoys reading Dahl and thought deWitt and Dahl have a similar style as both are highly imaginative, dark yarn spinners.
- Members enjoyed the use of Intermissions, but were perplexed over the Weeping Man, the Old Witch, and the Poisonous Little Girl. The facilitator provided author insight into these characters. Overall, the members enjoyed these seemingly unrelated vignettes.
- One member enjoyed The Sisters Brothers (deWitt’s second novel) so much, that she decided to read deWitt’s Undermajordomo Minor (deWitt’s third novel). She recommends this unusual novel, but thought The Sisters Brothers was overall a better novel.
Patrick deWitt discusses his novel with Jared Bland at the Toronto Public Library. deWitt discusses improving his craft, what writers should read, research, narrative voice choice, symbolism, and ending choice.