Morning Book Break Discussion on My Name Is Lucy Barton by Elizabeth Strout
Rating: My Name Is Lucy Barton received ratings between minus, minus, minus 1.0 (member sarcasm) and 4.5 with an average rating of 2.28. This is the lowest combined rating for a book discussed in Morning Book Break in the last four years.
Review: Unfortunately, due to the weather conditions and snow cover at the time of the meeting, many members were unable to join us for club. Some members were snowed in; nevertheless, many members did email the facilitator their comments and ratings. Hooray for participation from home! These comments/ratings were read aloud at the end of club during the critiquing session time. The members who were able to attend really enjoyed the in-depth discussion; they felt the discussion shed new light on the novel and elevated the reading experience. The discussion was thought-provoking and one member commented that each member present seemed to uncover a hidden element in the story that other members had not formerly discovered. My Name Is Lucy Barton is a novel that leaves so many things unsaid, leaving readers desiring to meet in clubs to piece together the story. Nancy Pearl, librarian and author of Book Lust, says My Name Is Lucy Barton is the perfect book club read, as it is a novel that lends itself to discuss what is not written on the page. Discussions will center on what is unsaid and clubs will enjoy working together to fill in the gaps.
Several members commented on how much they hated the book—this cannot be understated.
- Members stated that the writing was flat, vague, and too bare bones.
- Members did not like filling-in-the-blanks regarding specifics about the characters. Members felt they were left in the dark about many things in the novel.
- Members were frustrated and wished the author wrote more about the characters and their relationship to other another.
- Many members could not relate to the characters and didn’t care about the characters.
- Some members thought the book needed more character development.
- Some members thought the author demanded a lot from the reader, and they really did not want to work that hard to understand what was not written on the page.
Several members liked the book and three members thought the novel was exquisite.
- They enjoyed the cadence and the poetic language of the novel.
- They liked Strout’s skillful use of dialogue and her use of stream-of-consciousness like writing.
- Members liked the raw, emotional, and very real relationship between Lucy and her mother.
- Members enjoy books when authors’ require readers to fill-in-the-blanks and piece together the storyline.
- Members enjoyed the shared gossip between mother and daughter and felt this to be so very real. The gossip portrayed in the novel is the odd love language between mother and daughter and provides comfort to daughter during her hospitalization.
- Members like the “ruthless” aspect of Lucy which allowed her to overcome such a tragic beginning. (A father possibly suffering from PTSD and a mother with a possibly abusive past.)(Lucy suffers possible sexual abuse.)
- Members love the fact that Lucy as a child becomes a reader and later in life becomes a writer.
Members liked the metafictional aspects of the book.
- One member thought the take away message of the book was that we can overcome much, but some mistakes cannot be repaired—we only have one story(life).
- One member like the symbolism of the marble statue on display at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Lucy visits the statue again and again as it reminds her of the love/hate relationships she has with her parents and siblings—Lucy saw how really unhealthy her family was, but also “how our roots were twisted so tenaciously around one another’s hearts.”
- Members liked that the author’s writing allows the reader to engage at a variety of levels.
2:20-3:50 and 7:45-8:28 Elizabeth Strout discusses choice of first person narration and risks involved.
27:20-29:34 and 34:42-36:31 Elizabeth Strout answers the following questions:
“Your writing, at times, sounds mystical. Is that something you aim for?”
“Is Lucy or are any of your other characters, based in reality?”
“Was fiction writing always your aspiration, or were you drawn to other forms of literature at first?”
The facilitator thought Alice Munro’s writing to be very similar to Elizabeth Strout’s writing. An interesting note: Kimberly Farr is the reader for both audiobooks—Dear Life: Stories and My Name is Lucy Barton. Kimberly Farr excels in bringing the characters to life.
For other books by Elizabeth Strout in our collection, please click here.
We also own the mini-series Olive Kitteridge, based on Strout’s popular novel.