Books and Bagels and Morning Book Break Book Discussions on
The Rosie Project by Graeme Simsion
Ratings: In Books and Bagels, the book received ratings between 3.5 and 5.0. The average of the ratings was 4.36. Four members gave the book a 5. This is a high rating compare to other book club selections evaluated in past years.
In Morning Book Break, the book received ratings between a 2.5 and 5.0. The average of the ratings was 3.63.
Morning Book Break: While most members found the book discussion lively and interesting, they found the book, in general, to be a little disappointing. Many members found the writing to be tedious and slow-moving at times. They found the book to be an easy read, but not compelling. They thought the writing at the end was hurried—just like a film that wraps everything up in the last five minutes. A few members thoroughly enjoyed the book and found it to be quite humorous. Several members found the book educational in gently exposing the reader to Asperger’s Syndrome and/or the Autism Spectrum. One member stated that the main character, Don Tillman, was inspirational in striving to succeed without ever giving up. Several members relayed that it is helpful to read fiction to assist us in navigating our interactions with others. Fiction helps us to be sensitive to the needs of others. One member said, “the author showed if you move beyond the surface differences of a person, we all have something to offer, we all have value and strengths, and we all deserve respect and to be treated with dignity.”
Books and Bagels: The novel was well received by members. Members found the novel enlightening, engaging, and entertaining. Members found themselves frequently laughing aloud. Although, not necessary literary, they found the book fun and very clever. As an aside, the author claims he could have made the novel literary and award winning by changing several sentences at the end, but he claims he likes to write what people like to read. Members are looking forward to the movie and hope the casting does justice to the book’s characters. Several members thought about what actors should be cast in the roles of Don and Rosie. One member, who is not a fan of romance novels, constantly recommends this novel to colleagues as it is on her “top 10 list to recommend.” One member read the sequel, which she thoroughly enjoyed and she feels it is continuous part of this amazing story that everyone should read. Another member read the sequel and was disappointed in that, it was not of the same caliber as the debut.
- Gaining understanding of Asperger’s Syndrome and/or the Autism Spectrum via fiction.
- Discussed: What is love? And, Is it smart to have a list of criteria for a potential partner?
- Structure and chaos in our lives & routines in our lives (Helpful? Limiting?)
- Two secondary characters are involved in an open marriage. We discussed this concept.
- The Rosie Project was selected as the adult read for 2016-2017 by the Suburban Mosaic organization. The Mosaic’s goal is to foster cultural understanding through literature. The discussion groups were asked whether or not, this goal was achieved. Overall, both discussion groups found this novel to be excellent in achieving the goal of fostering some understanding of the Autism Spectrum, but, more importantly, understanding differences in people.
For other books by Graeme Simsion in our collection, please click here.
Bill & Melinda Gates interview Graeme Simsion about The Rosie Project
Graeme Simsion answers question for The Big Read: