Books and Bagels Book Discussion on
Everybody’s Fool by Richard Russo and Nobody’s Fool (DVD)
The book received ratings between a 3.5 and 5.0. One member gave the book a 2.00, but after the discussion was able to elevate her score to a 2.5. The average of the ratings was 4.23.
Members were asked to read Everybody’s Fool and watch the DVD Nobody’s Fool and then compare and contrast these two formats. Members were asked whether Russo revisited any themes or characters. What recurring characters have changed or remained the same? What do you think that the books offer collectively?
The members overall really enjoyed the movie, Nobody’s Fool. Several members gathered together to view the film—and they enjoyed this group experience. The members loved watching Paul Newman (Sully), Jessica Tandy (Miss Beryl), and Phillip Seymour Hoffman (Douglas Raymer) portrays Russo’s characters. The members miss these actors, just as Richard Russo misses them. Sully is partly based on Richard Russo’s father, but Russo believes Sully also, belongs to Paul Newman—he is the embodiment of Sully. Russo is hopeful that Everybody’s Fool will be optioned for a movie, but finds it hard to picture anyone else as Sully, Miss Beryl, or Douglas Raymer. Members enjoyed this format—watching a movie and then reading the sequel. Members felt more connected to the characters and followed the novel more readily by using this method.
Members loved the humor contained within the novel. During the book discussion, members laughed heartily as they recalled funny portions of the novel. Members found the writing style to be remarkable and the descriptions very perceptive about the human race. Although, the novel deals with very serious issues, members found the novel to be surprisingly uplifting. Members appreciated Russo’s ability to develop rich depictions of primary and secondary characters.
Next month, members will read Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis by J.D. Vance and they will be asked to compare and contrast the fictional portrayal of small town America (Everybody’s Fool) with the nonfiction portrayal (Hillbilly Elegy).
- Discussion about the title of the book and who the title might be referencing.
- Everybody’s Fool opens with a description of the local cemetery with several more visits throughout the novel. The group discussed the symbolism implied in the setting. Additional discussion about the North Bath and comparisons to the neighboring town of Schuyler Springs which led to an evaluation of fortune and luck experienced by different towns.
- Discussion about the various relationships presented in the novel.
- Discussed themes of aging, mortality, racism, prejudice and the treatment of women.
- The members discussed which characters they felt the most sympathy for and whether any characters significantly changed over the course of the novel. We discussed how and why the characters are vulnerable to the judgements of others
- Members discussed the theme of legacy and the influence of deceased characters throughout the story. Additionally, we discussed the role of secrets, complicity, and forgiveness in the novel.
- Of course, we discussed Russo’s use of comedy in the novel.
For other books and audiobooks by Richard Russo, please click here.
Richard Russo and Lori Ostlund in conversation at the Bay Area Book Festival.
Richard Russo discusses his recently-released novel with PBS correspondent Jeffrey Brown at Book Expo America 2016 in Chicago.
Richard Russo introduces Everybody’s Fool at University Book Store – Seattle
Amor Towles interviews Russo for Martha’s Vineyard Authors Series
Richard Russo is known for his ability to intricately draw secondary characters. In a recent interview, he commented that one of his core beliefs is that there are no small lives. What a tribute to the richness of all human life! This core belief definitely comes through in his writing.