Morning Book Break Book Discussion on
Beartown by Fredrik Backman
The book received ratings between a 0 and 5.0. The average of the ratings was 4.43.
This novel was selected for many reasons. A primary reason was this club’s real love for Fredrik Backman’s novel A Man Called Ove. This was, without exception, a club all-time favorite. Additionally, selections are made by the facilitator with potential discussions in mind. This club had never explored the role of sports in the US. The facilitator presented the TIME magazine (August 24, 2017) article entitled, “How Kids’ Sports Became a $15 Billion Industry.” The article states, “Across the U.S., the rise in travel teams has led to the kind of facilities arms race once reserved for big colleges and the pros. Cities and towns are using tax money to build or incentivize play-and-stay mega-complexes, betting that the influx of visitors will lift the local economy.” This is the backdrop of Beartown with the addition of a sexual assault which changes the dynamics of the town and its people.
Many members have fond memories of their children and grandchildren participating in sports. Sports were a part of family bonding and life-long lessons were imparted. Sports offered real opportunities for teachable moments. Several members recall their own pathetic partnership with sports. The members came from an era, where girls sports did not count and many are glad to see that girls have equal opportunities in this arena.
Members felt the author did a wonderful job describing the area—the member saw the winter scenes in their minds.
Members felt the writing was choppy and uneven. Members wondered if part of the problem was the translation from Swedish to English. The members felt the book was in desperate need of editing. One member felt 200 pages could be cut—members thought there was too much information presented about hockey. Facilitator shared that Fredrik Backman relayed information about his writing process. “Maybe I could put it like this: I have learned to build a box for me to play within. Which means I decide the world my character gets to explore, and the limits of it, and I try to write a beginning and an ending to the story first of all. That way I’m free to have new ideas within it, but I have certain boundaries that force me to actually finish the story at some point. Otherwise I would probably just keep on going and every novel would be 60,000 pages long.” Members laughed aloud as they could barely read his 400+ pages let alone 60,000 pages.
Members thought Backman used too many characters and they felt the characters were underdeveloped.
For the most part, members were not that interested in a novel that revolved around sports, particularly hockey.
Several members disliked the constant use of profanity throughout the novel. Some members wonder whether young adults really talk like they are portrayed in the novel.
Members would not recommend this novel to others.
- The group discussed what hockey means to the people of Beartown and what kind of community has been built by the people of Beartown.
- Discussion about the presentation of social classes in Beartown and the ways hockey can cut through class distinctions or reinforce them.
- We discussed the pressures applied to the hockey team by the town and the parents. We discussed what hockey demands from the boys. We discussed which parents were most successful at preparing their children for the real world.
- The group discussed the portrayal of several marriages in the novel and the views of various characters regarding working mothers.
- The group discussed the role of secrets in the novel.
- The author often chooses to not use first names, and we discussed how this decision affected our opinion of the various characters.
- In reading the novel, we saw that playing on a sports team teaches young people values like loyalty, responsibility, and commitment and it can also promote exclusion, aggression, and entitlement. We discuss whether there are behaviors that are rewarded in a sports competition but considered inappropriate in real life. We talked about which characters had difficulty navigating these behaviors.
- We discussed how Maya’s final act shapes her future and Kevin’s future. We talked about the characters who find the courage to go against the grain of the tight-knit Beartown community.
- We discussed whether the tradition of the Beartown Hockey Club will continue and if it will change going forward.
Barnes and Noble interview with Fredrik Backman
Fredrik Backman’s website which includes an interesting Q & A courtesy of Shelf Awareness:
For books and audiobooks in our collection by Fredrik Backman, please click here.
Everyone who attend both Books and Bagels & Morning Book Break Book Discussion Groups appreciated delving deeply into the current pulse of small town America. The groups explored the plight of “brain drain” through reading the following literature; Nobody’s Fool, Everybody’s Fool, Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis, and Beartown. It was a pleasure to explore this matter in a deeper way and make literary connections to current events.