Morning Book Break Book Discussion on
Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate
Rating: This book received a variety of scores between 2.0 and 5.0. In scoring, the mode was 4.0 and the average rating was 3.79.
Review: Only two members were aware of the abuses suffered under Georgia Tann and her adoption organization, the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. The book club members really appreciate learning about events in history, therefore, they found the historical information Wingate presented to be very interesting, heart-wrenching, and compelling. All members were willing to give this novel a high score (5.0) for the research and historical material presented.
The fictional facet of the novel received mixed reviews. Many members loved the book and they have been recommending it to friends and family. They found the topic fascinating and they spent time conducting further research on the events presented. Many members said the mysterious aspect of the novel grabbed them and they looked forward each day to reading the book. Many found it to be a well-written, easy-read.
The discussion was interesting in that an equal number of members found the writing to be sophomoric and contrived. Many criticized the novel as it was more like a script for a sappy Hollywood or Lifetime movie as opposed to a literary read. One member thought this might be a YA novel due to the writing style.
Members had differing opinions about the structure of the novel. Some members were frustrated that the author shifted from 1939 to Present Day throughout the novel. Many thought this would be a tremendous book without the Present Day chapters and they wished the novel just covered the historical material about the shanty boat children—everyone was invested in the Foss children. Some members questioned why so many contemporary novels utilize dual-narration. Members were confused by the amount of characters presented. One member said she took notes on the names of the characters and had to constantly revise the list. Members chuckled because they want to enjoy a book without having to take copious notes. Other members thoroughly appreciated the structure and felt it added an element of suspense to the novel.
- The dual-narration structure of the novel and clarification of some of the roles of the main characters.
- Discussion about the sisters’ decision to keep their family history secret. The group discussed whether family secrets should remain secret.
- Discussion about whether the birth parents were responsible or careless individuals.
- Was the ending realistic or unrealistic? What happens to Avery and Trent’s relationship?
- Why the novel received worldwide interest? What themes are universal?
- What can society do to prevent people like Georgia Tann from taking advantage of the most vulnerable?
A 60 Minutes report on the Tennessee Children’s Home Society scandal:
For other books by Lisa Wingate in our collection, please click here.